Which James?

This photo gives us a first name.

James with boys holding puppies

James with boys holding puppies

I believe James is the same boy in this photo:

James with girl on porch

James with girl on porch

However, there was more than one James in the family. Melvina Vandivier and husband Frank Hocker’s son James Hocker was born 2 Jan 1917 in Parke County. Sarah Amnie Wilson Vandivier and her husband Brownie Miller’s son James Ivan Miller was born 1923 in Indiana. Everett Vandivier and his wife Dorothy Overpeck also had a son James. Family resemblance doesn’t work well with a bunch of cousins.